Coral Reefs Types

Reef formation

The prime reef builders are the stony or hard corals (subphylum Anthozoa). Reefs are formed by the skeletons of the tiny coral polyps. A coral polyps consist of a fleshy sack with a ring of tentacles which sits in a limestone skeletal case, secreted by the polyp.

Reef-building corals have evolved an indispensable symbiotic relationship with a type of brown algae called zoxanthellae (Symbiodinium microadriaticum). Millions of these single-celled algae are living as symbionts within their tissues (hermatypic corals). Zooxanthellae produce sugars and oxygen through photosynthesis thus helping the coral in the process of producing limestone or calcium carbonate. Corals grow up to three times faster with the help of the zooxanthellae.

Zooxanthellae give the corals their characteristic greenish color. A change of environmental conditions such as higher temperatures or a change in salinity but also disease can cause the polyps to expel the algae. The coral becomes totally white (= coral bleaching). If the coral regains some algae it might survive, but bleaching can be irreversible and then the coral dies.

Coral poly open and closed and the empty cup

Top – End – Previous – Next

Coral reefs on earth

Corals need warm water, if possible temperatures should be between 18°C and 30°C. If the water is colder, the reefs are poorly developed or nonexistent. Most coral reefs lie between the latitudes of 30 degrees north and south where sea temperatures are warmest.

Corals need access to sunlight (the algae living in their cells need light for photosynthesis) so the water where they grow needs to be shallow and clear. Too much sediment in the water can smother the coral polyps and too much fresh water kills them. That is why coral reefs don’t grow close to the mouths of rivers.

Map of the reefs on earth

Reefs on earth

Orange = atolls / Red = fringing reefs / Green = barrier reefs

Top – End – Previous – Next

Types of reefs

Coral reefs are divided into four main types: fringing reef, platform reefs, barrier reefs and atolls.
Fringing reef Fringing reefs are relatively young. They can develop in shallow waters along the coast of tropical islands or continents. The corals grow upwards to sea level or just below and outwards towards the open ocean. Fringing reefs are generally narrow platforms a short distance from shore and don’t contain a substantial lagoon.

fringing reef

Fringing reef

plattform reef

Platform reef

Platform reef

Platform reefs usually lie in sheltered seas and quite far offshore. They are flat-topped with small and very shallow lagoons.

Barrier reef

barrier reef

A coral reef growing parallel to the coastline and separated from it by a lagoon is called a barrier reef. The lagoon may develop between the fringing reef and the land. As the reef continues to grow further and further offshore it eventually reaches the edge of the continental shelf. Barrier reefs can also originate offshore if the depth of the seabed out there is shallow enough to allow corals to grow.

The most famous barrier reef is the Great Barrier Reef in Australia. It stretches over 2300 km and covers over 200’000 km2. It lies between 24 and 240 km from the main continent.

Atoll

atoll

Atolls are rings of reef, often encircling an island (sand and coral rubble). They typically have a shallow, sandy, sheltered lagoon in the middle. Access to the open sea beyond is through a number of channels. These provide fresh and colder water for the lagoons. Corals atolls are on the top of submarine mountains. These mountains are remnants of volcanos. Once there were fringing reefs around the volcano. As it slowly submerged the corals continued to grow up to the surface of the water. What remained after the volcano became invisible is a ring of coral reefs surrounded by deep ocean.

However some atolls were probably formed by rising sea levels rather by the sinking of islands. Other theories suggest that corals colonized eroded limestone formations, so called karstic saucers.

fringing reef around a volcano

a fringing reef s

from the fringing reef to an atoll

urrounding an active volcano – subsidence of the seafloor or rising sea levels

shrinking of the island – an atoll results when the island has disappeared

Atoll

Platform reef

Bay with sandy beach

Lagoon

Lagoon

Inner lagoon

Fringing reef

Fringing reef

Reef flat

Island with small reef

Island with channels from run off water

Fishing village with channel

Top – End – Previous

Reef morphology

Reefs are often referred to as the “rainforests of the oceans”. Coral reefs host an extraordinary variety of marine plants and animals (perhaps up to 2 million) including one quarter of all marine fish species. The wide variety of habitats depends a lot on the morphology of the coral reef. The differences in temperatures, light, exposure to waves and tides, currents and the amount of food available result in different habitats and niches.

reef morphology

A) Mud flats close to shore with tide pools – B) Mangroves – C) Seagrass bed – D) Patch reefs on inner reef slope – E) Inner lagoon – F) bottom with mud – G) Pinnacle – H) Outer lagoon – I) Fine sand – K) Acropora corals – L) Algae ridge – M) Sand and rubble – N) Gorgonians and black corals – O) Cave or overhang

Coastal bays: Mangroves often live along the edge of bays and river mouths. The water is often turbid with silty bottoms. Mangroves provide shelter with their root system and are a nursing ground for many species of coral reef fishes.
Lagoons: Depths my vary from less than a meter to 90m. If there is good circulation of water there may be many patch reefs or just large stands of acropora corals growing there. There may be seagrass beds or mud flats. Lagoons can trap many fish varieties as tide recedes.
Channels: These connect the lagoons with the open water and are important to provide fresh and colder water for the lagoons. Tidal currents provide ideal conditions for plankton-feeding animals, so channel walls are often overgrown with soft and hard corals.
Inner reef slope: Sometimes there are be patch reefs. In an atoll these areas might be extensive and interesting for their rich life.
Reef flat: The shallow, flattest part of a reef, often partly eroded and uncovered at low tide. They can range from a few meter to a few kilometer. Depending on wave action and temperatures the surface may be just featureless or a complex maze of interconnecting channels, tide pools and sand patches. Coral growth is usually poor.
Reef front: Here the reef takes the full force of wave action. Growth of corals is restricted and usually there is a lot of rubble and sand. Visibility might be bad too because of the sediments raised by the tide and waves.
Outer reef slope: The seaward edge of a reef is fairly steep and slopes down to deeper water. Since the water is generally clearer, corals may grow to the depths of 50m depending on light available. There might be interesting caves, overhangs or gullies.
Drop-offs or walls: Some outer reef slopes are nearly vertical. Sand and sediment will only collect in terraces or shelves. There might be vertical chutes with sand. Currents are either horizontally along the wall or vertically up or down along the chutes.

level of variety in animal species in different habitats (reef front, reef flat, lagoons)

A = coarse sedimentation B = fine sedimentation C = daily variation of temperatures D = number of different species (according to H. Schumacher 1967)

source:http://www.starfish.ch

Posted in oceans | 1 Comment

Coral Reef Formation

There are several theories about how coral structures are formed. Charles Darwin originally described 3 major types of coral reefs.

The first of these types is the fringing reef, an area along the shore where coral colonies have been able to grow. Fringing reefs occur close to land and often extend out to sea for long distances.  The second type of reef is a barrier reef, a well defined coral zone separated from land by a lagoon. The lagoon is a shallow area with a sandy floor, patch reefs, and patches of seagrass.  An atoll is the third type of reef. An atoll is a ring-like formation of reefs with a lagoon inside the ring.

According to Darwin, barrier reefs begin as fringing reefs along the shores of a volcano. Over millions of years, the volcano sinks lower into the sea and the sea level rises around the volcano. The coral grows upwards to keep from getting too far from the sunlight at the sea surface. The outward side of the coral reef grows fastest since ocean currents bring in the plankton that the corals feed on. The water on the landward side of the reef is still and there is less oceanic plankton. Here the reef is unable to grow fast enough to keep up with the rising sea level and is eventually drowned. A lagoon develops between the reef and the land, resulting in the characteristic barrier reef shape.  The volcano continues sinking until it disappears under the sea surface. The result is an atoll, a ring of coral reefs surrounding the submerged, extinct volcano. Eventually sand is trapped by the reefs and sandy islands, called cays, appear. The word “keys”, as in Florida Keys, derives from the Spanish word “cay.”

The Reefs of Bermuda

Bermuda has been classified as an atoll, but more correctly it should be called a pseudoatoll. This is because the process that formed Bermuda is different than the process that forms an atoll. In Bermuda, sands have collected, been compressed, and turned into rock by a process known as lithification.  The land formations of Bermuda are much taller than the formations of the true Pacific atolls.

Look at these two views of Bermuda islands.  The one on the left was taken from space and shows the patterns of green and white on land due to trees and houses.  The patterns of blue indicate the depth of water with the lightest color the shallowest water. (If you click on the island you can view a larger image.)

Compare the actual photo with the drawing.  The faint lines around the platform are the depth contours of 200 and 1000 meters.  The Terrace Reef Zone is indicated in black and the Rim Reef Zone is is grey.  BBSR is located on the island of St. George at the eastern end of the country.

The Bermuda platform is the area incorporating the islands, the lagoon, the rim area and the main terrace of Bermuda.

A cross section of the Bermuda atoll shows the location of these different reef formations.  The lagoon is called the North Lagoon and has a depth that ranges between 10 and 20 meters. The waters inside the North Lagoon are calmer and are home to numerous individual patches of corals called patch or lagoonal reefs. One of the disadvantages of the low wave environment is the problem of increased amounts of silt falling on the corals. These reefs which come in many different shapes and sizes, are surrounded by sand. Branching corals, such as Madracis, Oculina, the fire coral Millepora alcicornis, and soft corals such as the sea rod Pseudoplexaura, flourish in this calmer environment.

The rim reefs create a circle along the edge of the lagoon and are formed on the raised rim of the Bermuda platform. They range in depth between 2 and 10 meters. North Rock is an example of a rim reef area. Many different hard corals, especially massive boulder corals such as Brain and Star corals are abundant here, as well as sea rods and sea fans such as the large Gorgonia.

“Boilers” occur on the southern and southeastern side of the island and are part of the rim reef system. They are small, generally rounded reefs that extend to the sea surface and have waves continuously breaking over them. This makes the water look as though it is boiling.  The picture here was taken while scouting for sites to put the underwater camera seaward of the rim area.

source:http://www.coexploration.org

 

Posted in oceans | 4 Comments

Global Warming: Definitions,Causes,Trends, Effects and Climate Change

Definition of Global Warming: Gradual increase in the earth’s surface temperature.
Popular usage definition: Warming caused by human activity.
Technical term for this: Anthropogenic global warming.
Definition of Greenhouse Gas: A gas, like CO2, which traps the sun’s heat.The debate: Is the observed global warming natural or man made?

Human causes: Carbon dioxide (CO2), e.g. exhaust from cars and power plants.
Natural causes: Some claim the sun is getting hotter.

U.S. Government Position: The Energy Act of 2005 states: “the President shall establish a Committee on Climate Change Technology [which] shall submit to the Secretary and the President a national strategy to promote the deployment and commercialization of greenhouse gas intensity reducing technologies and practices.”

History: In 1896 Svante Arrhenius (1903 Nobel Prize in Chemistry) predicted the decrease in CO2 needed to cause past ice ages. He wasn’t far off, and it is not a large decrease. This helped confirm the 1859 prediction that human-produced increases in CO2 would cause just the reverse: global warming.

-CO2-Temp-S

What Causes Global Warming, human activity or the sun? The final answer is not in, but you can see the results so far. (1) Exhaust is clearly the source of CO2. (2) Everyone now agrees the earth is warming. (3) Decide for yourself if warming is better explained by CO2, or the sun’s heat.

Stoft  2005 09 hurricane global warming-S

The Effects of Global Warming. We can see the long-term effects coming in the melting of polar ice and glaciers. But a powerful trend in Atlantic hurricane data indicates we can already see the impact. Katrina was partly the result of a normal weather cycle, but that cannot explain away stronger hurricanes world wide.

-CO2-predicted-measured-S

Can we Stop Global Warming?
It’s too late for that, but we can slow it down and lessen its effects. CO2 does not last as long in the air as was once thought, so the big problem is slowing human use of fossil energy, especially coal. (Especially since CO2 goes into the ocean and destroys coral reefs.)

The phrase global warming refers to the documented historical warming of the Earth’s surface based upon worldwide temperature records that have been maintained by humans since the 1880s.  The term global warming is often used synonymously with the term climate change, but the two terms have distinct meanings.  Global warming is the combined result of anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases and changes in solar irradiance, while climate change refers to changes caused by global warming in weather (temperatures, precipitation, frequency of heat waves, etc.) and other climate system components, such as Arctic sea ice extent.

Enlarge

According to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the decade of 1998-2007 is the warmest on record. The global mean surface temperature for 2007 is currently estimated at 0.41°C/0.74°F above the 1961-1990 annual average of 14.00°C/57.20°F. WMO states that among other remarkable global climatic events recorded in 2007, a record-low Arctic sea ice extent was observed which led to first recorded opening of the Canadian Northwest Passage.

The United States National Climatic Data Center (NCDC), found that in 2006 “Globally averaged land temperatures were +0.78°C (+1.40°F) and ocean temperatures +0.45°C (+0.81°F) above average, ranking 4th and 5th warmest, respectively. The land and ocean surface temperatures for the Northern and Southern Hemisphere ranked 2nd and 6th warmest, respectively,” since global temperature record monitoring began in 1880. The NCDC report states that “during the past century, global surface temperatures have increased at a rate near 0.06°C/decade (0.11°F/decade) but this trend has increased to a rate approximately 0.18°C/decade (0.32°F/decade) during the past 25 to 30 years. There have been two sustained periods of warming, one beginning around 1910 and ending around 1945, and the most recent beginning about 1976.”

The NCDC’s Preliminary Annual Report on the Climate of 2007 (released December 13, 2007) states that:

  • “the global annual temperature for combined land and ocean surfaces for 2007 is expected to be near 58.0°F and would be the fifth warmest since records began in 1880,” and that
  • “the year 2007 is on pace to become one of the 10 warmest years for the contiguous U.S., since national records began in 1895.”
Enlarge

Global in Situ Temperature Anomalies and Trends, Surface and Mid Troposphere (Jan-Dec).

The NCDC 2006 report also described temperature trends aloft in the atmosphere measured over the past 50 to 60 years using balloon-borne instruments (radiosondes) and for the past 28 years using satellites. The report states that temperature data collected from approximately 5,000 to 30,000 feet above the surface indicate that 1958-2006 global temperature trends in the middle troposphere are similar to trends in surface temperature; 0.12°C/decade for surface and 0.15°C/decade for mid-troposphere.

On 2 February 2007, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released the Summary For Policymakers (SPM), an executive summary of the first volume of its 4th Assessment Report entitled, “The Physical Science Basis of Climate Change.” The IPCC Report documents that not only do the records show a warming trend during the past half century in land-based temperature data but also in global ocean temperature measurements. The increases in ocean temperatures indicate global warming trends are not an artifact of urbanization or the so-called “heat-island” effect.

U.S. Trends

The NCDC Report also documents not only a long-term warming trend for the globe as a whole but also a warming trend for the contiguous United States. The Report documents that the 2006 average annual temperature for the contiguous U.S. was the warmest on record and nearly identical to the record set in 1998.

Enlarge

Mean temperature values for the contiguous U.S. in the NCDC data set were calculated using a network of more than 1,200 U.S. Historical Climatology Network stations. These data, primarily from rural stations, have been adjusted to remove artificial effects resulting from factors such as urbanization and station and instrument changes which occurred during the period of record.

Causes of Global Warming

In the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report scientists conclude that “warming of the climate system is unequivocal, as is now evident from observations of increases in global average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice, and rising global average sea level” and, furthermore, they conclude with “very high confidence (at least a 9 out of 10 chance of being correct) that the globally averaged net effect of human activities since 1750 has been one of warming” of the Earth’s climate system.

Enlarge

As with every environmental variable, there are multiple factors that contribute to the “warmth” of the Earth. Humans measure warmth as temperature which is a measure of the amount of heat contained in a physical object. One can envision this concept by thinking of a pot on a stove. As heat is applied to the pot from a flame or heating element, the temperature of the pot will increase. But heat will also begin escaping the pot in the form of steam and also through radiative and convective cooling from the top and the sides of the pot. Eventually the rates of both heat loss (cooling) and heat gain (warming) may stabilize and the heat then contained within the pot at an instantaneous point of time would be reflected in an equilibrium temperature. This equilibrium temperature could be measured directly but it also could be calculated by determining all of the flux rates of heat entering (heating) and leaving (cooling) the pot.

One way that climate scientists look at the warmth of the Earth’s climate system is to calculate the annual average temperature of the surface of the Earth using temperature measurements systematically collected throughout the year from thousands of land- and ocean-based weather and observation stations. The observed trends in the Earth’s annual average temperature is one of the factors leading to the scientific conclusion that the Earth is now in a period of global warming.

In order to attempt to answer why the Earth is currently warming, scientists have conducted accountings of each of the fluxes of heat into (warming) and out of (cooling) the Earth’s climate system. Since the measured data show that annual average temperatures of the Earth have been increasing in recent decades, the year-to-year annual flux of heat into the climate system must be greater than the annual flux of heat out of the system. By accounting for each of the fluxes of heat into and out of the system, scientists are able to assess which fluxes and processes are contributing to net annual warming of the Earth’s surface. By conducting such accountings, scientists are able to quantify the influence that each natural and human factor has in altering the balance of incoming and outgoing energy in the Earth-atmosphere system and can calculate an index of the importance of each of the factor as a potential climate change mechanism. Each of the factors are called climate drivers and the relative impact or index of each factor’s importance to climate change is called its radiative forcing.

Enlarge

In completing such an assessment, the IPCC has concluded with very high confidence that the globally averaged net effect of human activities since 1750 has been one of warming. The scientists found that the combined radiative forcing due to increases in carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide is the largest climate driver and its rate of increase during the industrial era is very likely to have been unprecedented in more than 10,000 years. Furthermore, the carbon dioxide radiative forcing increased by 20% from 1995 to 2005, the largest change for any decade in at least the last 200 years.

The IPCC also found that anthropogenic contributions to aerosols in the atmosphere produce cooling effects, referred to as global dimming. However the cooling (global dimming) effects due to human-caused aerosols are equivalent to about half of the warming effects due to the combined radiative forcing of human-produced greenhouse gases, causing a net warming.

Significant anthropogenic contributions to radiative forcing were also found to have come from several other sources, including tropospheric ozone changes due to emissions of ozone-forming chemicals, direct radiative forcing due to changes in halocarbons, and changes in surface albedo, due to land-cover changes and deposition of black carbon aerosols on snow. However the impacts of each of these factors was relatively small compared to the impacts of anthropogenic greenhouse gases (each showing relative impacts of 15% or less relative to the greenhouse gas forcings).

Finally, an increase in solar irradiance since 1750 was estimated to have caused a forcing that contributed to the recent warming of the Earth. However, the impact of the increase in the amount of sunlight striking the Earth each year during this ~250 year time span was estimated to be only about 1/20th of the warming impacts of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions.

Climate Change

weather

Climate change refers to the variation at a global or regional level over time. It describes the variability or average state of the atmosphere or average weather over time scales ranging from decades to millions of years. These variations may come from processes internal to the Earth, be driven by external forces (e.g. variations in sunlight intensity) or, most recently, be caused by human activities.


If you are not sure of the difference between ‘climate’ and ‘weather’, click on the link to find out: Climate-Weather.

No time to read all this? For a quick one page summary on the Facts and Impacts go

hereor listen to four scientists from Columbia University explain future climatic uncertainties. With Peter DeMenocal, Gavin Schmidt, Maxx Dilly and Klaus Lackner.


Why do you think we measure weather?
Find out here

Just as weather patterns change from day to day, the climate changes too. This occurs naturally, driven by internal and external factors. However not all changes are due to natural processes, as we humans have also exerted our influence ( anthropogenic climate change). Through widespread use of land, and the building of cities, we have changed our climate. The major technological and socioeconomic shift of the industrial era with reduced reliance on organic fuel, the accelerated uptake of fossil fuels, and broad scale deforestation, means we have contributed to the natural greenhouse effect.

The key areas for concern are those related to variability and extremes, not simply changed average conditions. There is an accumulating body of evidence of observed impacts relating to regional changes, and that these are having fearful effects on the world around us.

There are already people who have become climate refugees, and millions more are expected in the future. Temperatures across the globe are most certainly rising; the 1990s was the warmest decade in the last thousand years. Sea surface temperatures have increased 0.4-0.8°C (0.7-1.4°F) since the late 19 Century, and over the period 1961 to 2003, global ocean temperature has risen by 0.10°C (0.18°F) from the surface to a depth of 700 m.

millenium temperature

The world has warmed 0.74°C in the past hundred years and scientists are clear that the world will get warmer this century due to further increases in greenhouse gas concentrations. Global average temperature is forecast to rise 4°C (7.2°F) toward the end of the 21st century. Warming of a few degrees seems inconsequential compared with day to day, or seasonal variations in temperature. However, in global terms it is much larger than any of the climatic changes experienced during the past 10,000 years, since the rise of agriculture and civilisations. Although the Earth has seen many climatic changes during its 4.6 billion year history, the current changes are spurred by the human burning of fossil fuels.

In addition to warming of the Earth’s surface, there has been an increase in heatwaves, warming of the lower atmosphere and deep oceans. There are fewer frosts, permafrost is melting, glaciers are retreating and sea ice is decreasing. Sea levels have risen 10–20 cm and there is increased heavy rainfall in some regions, and less in others.

Climatic changes over recent decades have already affected some health outcomes. The World Health Organisation estimated, in its “World Health Report 2002”, that climate change was estimated to be responsible in 2000 for approximately 2.4% of worldwide diarrhoea, and 6% of malaria in some middle-income countries. Epidemics of weather and climate-sensitive infectious diseases such as malaria and meningitis will have a devastating effect on human health and socio-economic development and severely overburden health systems in many parts of the world.

The Fourth Assessment Report released in 2007, by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) stated that “there is new and stronger evidence that most of the warming observed over the last 50 years is attributable to human activities”. As seen below, The Report also shows why there is cause for deep concern:

Hydrology and Glaciers – Glaciers are retreating, and snow cover is decreasing (e.g. Davos in the Swiss Alps) with earlier snowmelt, and changing snow ecology. There is also reductions in the annual duration of lake and river ice.

Sea Ice – Declining sea-ice extent and thickness.

Animals – Poleward and elevational shifts in range, and alteration in species abundance (e.g. Sea Turtles ). Over a million species are predicted to become extinct by 2050 (e.g. Boyd’s Forest Dragon, Cassowaries ). Changes in phenology (including earlier reproduction and migration), physiological and morphological adaptation.

Plants Change in abundance, diversity, and range, change in phenology (including earlier flowering), change in growth.

The Australian Government, whilst not signing the Kyoto Protocolhave acknowledged, “The projected global warming of a few degrees in the 21st century would occur at a time that is already one of the warmest for hundreds of thousands of years, with current levels of carbon dioxide not exceeded for the past 420,000 years, and not likely during the past 20 million years”.

A few degrees of global warming will lead to more heat waves and fewer frosts. More wildfires and droughts are expected in some regions of the world with higher rainfalls and resultant flooding in other areas. Higher latitudes of the globe would receive more rainfall while middle latitudes, including parts of Australia, are likely to receive less. For these areas the changes will pose significant problems for water resource management.

Tropical hurricanes and cyclones may become stronger and sea level may rise 9 to 88 cm by the year 2100. Some low-lying coastal areas and islands could be more prone to inundation from storm surges. Human induced climate change is another major stress in a world where natural and social systems are already experiencing pollution, increasing resource demands and unsustainable management practices.

links

http://www.eoearth.org/article/Global_warming

http://zfacts.com

http://www.global-greenhouse-warming.com

Posted in Global Warming | 7 Comments

Acid rain: One of the most important environmental problems

The term acid rain refers to what scientists call acid deposition.  It is caused by airborne acidic pollutants and has highly destructive results. Scientists first discovered acid rain in 1852, when the English chemist Robert Agnus invented the term.  From then until now, acid rain has been an issue of intense debate among scientists and policy makers.Acid rain, one of the most important environmental problems of all, cannot be seen.  The invisible gases that cause acid rain usually come from automobiles or coal-burning power plants.Acid rain moves easily, affecting locations far beyond those that let out the pollution.  As a result, this global pollution issue causes great debates between countries that fight over polluting each other’s environments.

For years, science studied the true causes of acid rain.  Some scientists concluded that human production was primarily responsible, while others cited natural causes as well.  Recently, more intensive research has been done so that countries have the information they need to prevent acid rain and its dangerous effects. The levels of acid rain vary from region to region.  In Third World nations without pollution restrictions, acid rain tends to be very high.  In Eastern Europe, China, and the Soviet Union, acid rain levels have also risen greatly.  However, because acid rain can move about so easily, the problem is definitely a global one.

source:http://greenplanet1.wordpress.com

Posted in Environment | 4 Comments